Maytag MFI2570FEZ00

Refrigerator · 5 documented failures, each with the part, the price, the video and the manual page.

We earn a commission on Amazon purchases made through links on this page. It never changes how causes are ranked or what a part costs you.

Owner's manual: Maytag MFI2570FEZ00 Use & Care Guide crosswalked by its exact parts catalog to document W10857667. (troubleshooting pp. 13-15)

What is it doing?

Documented failures

Start relay

Usually DIY

The start relay itself is a genuinely owner-replaceable part - it clips on and off the outside of the compressor. The compressor and its sealed refrigerant system are different: never open refrigerant lines or attempt to recharge the system yourself - that requires EPA Section 608 certification. If a new relay doesn't bring the compressor to life, the compressor itself or the sealed system is the next suspect, and that's a certified technician's job.

Try this first — it costs nothing. There's no free fix for a failed start relay - it's a low-cost, clip-on part, but it does need replacing, not repairing.

Check, in this order

  1. Listen for a repeated clicking sound near the compressor every few minutes - that's the classic start-relay symptom, the compressor trying and failing to start.
  2. Confirm the fridge is actually receiving power (outlet, cord, breaker) before suspecting the relay.
  3. Pull the relay off the compressor terminals and shake it gently - a rattle can indicate a failed relay, though this isn't conclusive on its own.

Before you open anything

Tools

The repair, in order

  1. Unclip the compressor terminal cover and locate the relay/overload assembly clipped to the compressor's side terminals.
  2. Photograph the wiring before removing anything.
  3. Pull the relay off the terminals and test it with the multimeter's continuity function between its terminals.
  4. Fit the replacement relay onto the compressor terminals in the same orientation, and refit the terminal cover.

How you know it worked. The compressor starts and runs without clicking, and the fridge pulls down to temperature over the following hours.

In your manual: the manual — checked; its troubleshooting section does not cover this part.

Component demonstration
Whirlpool Matrix Refrigerator Start Relay Replacement W11092533RepairClinic.com · not filmed on this specific model; the procedure is for the component

PartTypeListingPricePrice checked
W10798748OEMupmbzie Refrigerator Compressor Start Relay W11092533 W10798748 Genuin$51.9911 Aug 2026Buy
W10798748AftermarketW11092533 W10798748 Refrigerator Compressor Start Relay Direct Replace$51.9911 Aug 2026Buy
W11092533OEMupmbzie Refrigerator Compressor Start Relay W11092533 W10798748 Genuin$51.9911 Aug 2026Buy
W11092533AftermarketW11092533 Refrigerator Compressor Start Relay Compatible with Whirlpoo$54.0011 Aug 2026Buy
Prices are a snapshot taken on the date shown and are not monitored. Check the retailer before buying.

Worth fixing? Repair - the part is a small fraction of a new machine. Part $51.99–$54.00 against $1,399.99 for a new machine (3.9%).Part cost only. A service call adds a regional diagnostic fee plus labour.

Ice maker

Usually DIY

DIY. Call someone if the fill valve or water line inside the cabinet is involved.

Try this first — it costs nothing. Check the ice maker is switched on and the water supply is open - the manual's first two causes need no parts.

Check, in this order

  1. Give it the manual's 12 hours after any install or reset before judging it.
  2. Confirm the freezer is below 0 F - the manual lists a warm freezer as a cause of no ice.
  3. Check the dispenser lock is off, the ice maker is switched on, and the water line stop cock is open.
  4. Hollow or small cubes point at the water filter or supply rather than the ice maker.

Before you open anything

Tools

The repair, in order

  1. Give it the manual's 12 hours after any install or reset before calling it faulty.
  2. Confirm the freezer is below 0 F - the manual lists a warm freezer as a cause of no ice.
  3. Check the water line and stop cock, and that the dispenser lock is off.
  4. If ice is hollow or small, replace the water filter before the ice maker.
  5. Photograph the harness, unclip the assembly, fit the replacement.

How you know it worked. A full harvest within 24 hours, cubes solid rather than hollow.

In your manual: The ice maker is not producing ice or not enough ice — page 14

Component demonstration
Whirlpool Refrigerator Replace Ice Maker Auger Motor W10309868RepairClinic.com · not filmed on this specific model; the procedure is for the component

PartTypeListingPricePrice checked
W10309868OEMWhirlpool W10309868 Refrigerator Auger Motor (Replaces W10309868) Genu$89.9511 Aug 2026Buy
W10309868AftermarketClimaTek Refrigerator Auger Motor Replaces Maytag W10309868$62.7011 Aug 2026Buy
Prices are a snapshot taken on the date shown and are not monitored. Check the retailer before buying.

Worth fixing? Repair - the part is a small fraction of a new machine. Part $62.70–$89.95 against $1,399.99 for a new machine (6.4%).Part cost only. A service call adds a regional diagnostic fee plus labour.

Dispenser

Usually DIY

DIY.

Try this first — it costs nothing. Deactivate the dispenser lock and clear any ice jam in the chute - both are manual-listed, no-part causes.

Check, in this order

  1. Check the dispenser lock is off.
  2. Look for ice jamming the chute - the manual notes jams after about three weeks unused.
  3. Confirm the water filter is not overdue.

Before you open anything

Tools

The repair, in order

  1. Check the dispenser lock is off and the filter is not overdue.
  2. Look for ice jamming the chute - the manual notes ice jams after about three weeks unused.
  3. Photograph the harness before removing the dispenser assembly.

How you know it worked. Both water and ice dispense normally.

In your manual: The water and ice dispenser will not operate properly — page 15

Component demonstration
Whirlpool Refrigerator Ice Dispenser Solenoid #W10309866RepairClinic.com · not filmed on this specific model; the procedure is for the component

PartTypeListingPricePrice checked
W10309866AftermarketProretailer W10309866 Solenoid for Whirlpool Refrigerator 1876178 AH34$94.0011 Aug 2026Buy
WPW10368730OEMWhirlpool WPW10368730 Genuine OEM Refrigerator Dispenser Actuator Pad $116.5211 Aug 2026Buy
WPW10368730AftermarketWPW10368730 Durable Refrigerator Pad compatible with W10212876 W102128$130.3111 Aug 2026Buy
Prices are a snapshot taken on the date shown and are not monitored. Check the retailer before buying.

Worth fixing? Repair - the part is a small fraction of a new machine. Part $94.00–$130.31 against $1,399.99 for a new machine (9.3%).Part cost only. A service call adds a regional diagnostic fee plus labour.

Control board

Usually DIY

Get a technician to confirm before buying a board. It is the most expensive part here and the most commonly misdiagnosed.

Try this first — it costs nothing. Power-cycle the fridge at the wall for five minutes before assuming a board fault.

Check, in this order

  1. Rule out fans, sensor, damper and door switch first - the board is the expensive part they all get blamed for.
  2. Inspect the board for scorching or swollen capacitors.

Before you open anything

Tools

The repair, in order

  1. Rule out the cheaper causes first - fans, sensor, damper, door switch.
  2. Inspect the board for scorching or swollen capacitors.
  3. Transfer connectors one at a time against your photographs.

How you know it worked. Normal cooling and display behaviour over 24 hours.

In your manual: the manual — checked; its troubleshooting section does not cover this part.

PartTypeListingPricePrice checked
W10438707OEMGenuine Refurbished Refrigerator Control Board W10438707 Same Day Ship$54.9911 Aug 2026Buy
W10438707AftermarketGeneric Replacement for Whirlpool Refrigerator Control W10438707$58.7911 Aug 2026Buy
W10886279OEMOEM Replacement for Whirlpool Fridge Control W10886279 ~ ~$101.9911 Aug 2026Buy
W10886279AftermarketW10438707, W11035752, AP6327265, WPW10438707, W10886279 for Whirlpool $129.0011 Aug 2026Buy
WPW10438707AftermarketW10438707 WPW10438707 for Whirlpool Maytag Amana Refrigerator Main Boa$88.0011 Aug 2026Buy
Prices are a snapshot taken on the date shown and are not monitored. Check the retailer before buying.

Worth fixing? Repair - the part is a small fraction of a new machine. Part $54.99–$129.00 against $1,399.99 for a new machine (9.2%).Part cost only. A service call adds a regional diagnostic fee plus labour.

Door seal

Usually DIY

DIY.

Try this first — it costs nothing. Clean the gasket - the manual lists a dirty gasket as a frost cause, and a warmed, reshaped gasket often seals again.

Check, in this order

  1. Do the paper test: close a sheet of paper in the door and pull - it should drag on all four sides.
  2. Look for frost or condensation forming near the door edge, which the manual attributes to a door not closing properly.
  3. Check the gasket for tears, and for food or a drawer holding the door open.

Before you open anything

Tools

The repair, in order

  1. Clean the gasket first - the manual lists a dirty gasket as a frost cause.
  2. Do the paper test: close a sheet of paper in the door and pull; it should drag.
  3. Warm a deformed gasket gently with a hair dryer and reshape before buying one.
  4. If torn, peel the old gasket from its channel and press the new one in from the corners out.

How you know it worked. Paper test drags on all four sides and frost does not return at the door edge.

In your manual: The doors will not close completely — page 14

PartTypeListingPricePrice checked
W10163991AftermarketW10830055 Refrigerator Door Gasket Replacement for Whirlpool Kantar Fa$52.9911 Aug 2026Buy
W10443238AftermarketUpgraded W10830055 Refrigerator Door Gasket Replacement for Whirlpool $49.9911 Aug 2026Buy
W10830055OEMWhirlpool W10830055 OEM French Refrigerator Door Gasket$115.6811 Aug 2026Buy
W10830055AftermarketUpgarde W10830055 Refrigerator Door Gasket Replacement Compatible with$45.8811 Aug 2026Buy
Prices are a snapshot taken on the date shown and are not monitored. Check the retailer before buying.

Worth fixing? Repair - the part is a small fraction of a new machine. Part $45.88–$115.68 against $1,399.99 for a new machine (8.3%).Part cost only. A service call adds a regional diagnostic fee plus labour.

If you replace it instead

Configuration-matched to this machine (bottom-freezer, automatic, ~24.7 cu ft). Prices are UPC-verified Amazon listings, not estimates. Like-for-like replacement rarely pays for itself on energy alone — replace for fit and features, or because the repair maths above says so.

ModelCapacityEnergy costPricePrice checked
Durra Elite DE210FDBMDSS22.4 cu ft$111.10/yr$1,399.9919 Jul 2026See it
Kenmore 7564#22.3 cu ft$110.53/yr$1,438.9919 Jul 2026See it
Samsung RF24BB6200**
Digits marked * vary by colour/finish; any model in this series matches.
24.0 cu ft$118.63/yr$1,499.2219 Jul 2026See it
A candidate must match this machine's configuration (style, fuel and defrost class) before price or efficiency is considered. Prices are a snapshot from the date shown; availability is not monitored — check the retailer before buying.
Or see the whole class

We rank every refrigerator we hold certification data for, within its own size and configuration class, so you are comparing machines that would fit the same space. See the refrigerator rankings →